With this being a milestone episode, I'm doing a solo episode because there’s a topic I really want to discuss. It's a question I think so many nonprofits are wrestling with right now, as they navigate as marketers and fundraisers in this time where undivided attention seems increasingly scarce.
It’s a question I saw writ large at a recent conference: the Nonprofit Innovation & Optimization Summit, or the NIO Summit. It’s an annual conference that brings in nonprofit professionals from the U.S., Canada, and beyond.
I was asked to speak, which was a memorable experience, discussing nonprofit storytelling with 600 people in the crowd. But I also sat in the crowd and listened to most of the other speakers, and I could see before me the very clear crossroads so many of you are facing in the nonprofit storytelling space: quantity vs. quality.
In some ways this is an age-old debate. But it’s right there in front of all of us now because of a variety of changes to the storytelling landscape.
(Episode transcribed electronically)
Matt Pearl: Hello, friends! This is Episode 20 of Dot Org – the podcast all about how nonprofits tell their stories. I am your host, Matt Pearl. I was a broadcast journalist – a TV news reporter – for 20 years. Now I run Pearl Impact Media, where I craft videos for nonprofits that get used and remembered. In addition to that, I also host this podcast, where we help YOU build your nonprofit’s storytelling strategy.
Twenty episodes. We’ve been doing basically one a month since I started Pearl Impact Media, and it’s great to be at a number ending in zero. And this is a special one. Normally I’d be interviewing a special guest in the nonprofit space, someone who can share their organization’s approach to nonprofit storytelling. But with this being a milestone episode, I decided to do something different, especially because there’s a topic I really want to discuss … a question I think so many nonprofits are wrestling with right now as they navigate as marketers and fundraisers in this time where undivided attention seems increasingly scarce. It’s a question I saw writ large at a recent conference: the Nonprofit Innovation & Optimization Summit, or the NIO Summit. It’s an annual conference that brings in nonprofit professionals from the U.S., Canada … I even met one guest from Honduras. I was asked to speak, which was a memorable experience, discussing nonprofit storytelling with 600 people in the crowd. But I also sat in the crowd and listened to most of the other speakers … and I could see before me the very clear crossroads so many of you are facing in the nonprofit storytelling space: quantity vs. quality.
In some ways this is an age-old debate. But it’s right there in front of all of us now because of a variety of changes to the storytelling landscape.
Let’s start with the argument for quantity. Several of the speakers at NIO were very firmly on the side of quantity. They came out and said, "You've got to stack up content on every possible platform you can do it on.” That could be anything. I mean, one guy mentioned building a podcast and a YouTube series, and it all sounds great in theory, right? But the whole time, I was sitting there thinking, “What's it going to contain?” And can you have tentacles everywhere and actually get the results you're looking for?
Because if you're posting everywhere, but your attentions are so divided that none of the content is really worth it, and people see your content and are either disappointed in it or think it's AI slop, then what good are you really doing for your organization?
You know, I feel the same way about these companies that promise cold outreach, and they just bombard people with text messages. It's like, well, you might get a few responses. But you are taking an action that is such a turnoff for most people that you might just be damaging your larger brand awareness in the long term. So that’s my general feeling on the quantity approach – and whether it’s worth leaning into generative AI and resources like that to do it.
Now, when it comes to quality, the biggest question is the flip side of that, right? Its: If you're only posting a little bit at a time, and you're only focusing on one or two platforms, how is that going to get you big-time results?
And I would say that, typically, the size of your marketing department reflects the size of your organization, right?
So, I’m on the board of Lekotek of Georgia, and I’ve talked a lot about Lekotek before. I’ve had our executive director as a guest – which, by the way, has thus far been the most listened-to episode of DOT ORG. We talked all about building your nonprofit’s storytelling culture. And at Lekotek, where the annual revenue is a million dollars a year, we have nobody on staff whose sole job is marketing. We have staff members who help out with marketing. We have one person who takes it on as kind of an added responsibility to her job. And we have board members who pitch in here and there, but we don't have anybody on staff. And I think that’s pretty typical for an organization our size.
And yet, we have managed to build a storytelling culture at our organization that serves the purpose that we need it for.
We focus on where our families are, and we communicate with them there. At the start, it was Facebook. We've moved to a combination of that and Instagram, with a little bit of LinkedIn here and there sprinkled in. But we're very cautious about advancing to a new platform, because while it's good to be present on platforms, it doesn't necessarily guarantee you the results that you're looking for, and the awareness that you're looking for.
And I would say that's a huge part of all of this: figuring out where are my people, and what do we want them to do when they see the content that they're going to see?
Because here’s the thing: If you're just hoping that somebody's going to stumble upon a video on YouTube of yours, and suddenly they're going to be locked in and want to subscribe and want to donate to everything you do, I think that's a very long shot. The much safer bet is knowing where your people are, connecting with them as directly as you can with information that they'll want, and then testing your content: figuring out what to share, seeing what they respond to, seeing what they find valuable, seeing what gets them to take the actions you want them to take.
To me, that is certainly a safer use of resources, primarily because you're not going to burn anybody out in the process.
Secondly, it helps ensure your voice, right? You've got to have guardrails. And every time you automate processes or spread yourself a little too thin, you potentially open up your organization to either dilution of your brand voice, or even worse, something that goes against your philosophy and your mission.
Now, I would also say that when I go to these conferences, most of the examples that speakers use are from massive nonprofit organizations. You know how many times I've seen Charity: Water represented? Charity: Water has an annual revenue in the high-eight figures. And they have the ability to have a full team that can handle these sorts of things.
I've worked with massive organizations. And usually, when they hire me, it's as a supplementary piece or a complementary piece to something they're already doing, right? They've already got five people who do video. They just need one person for this specific project, and they want it to feel consistent with the other work that they've done.
So when I attend these conferences, and I see these examples, I really don't know how they apply to nonprofits that make — you know, forget about the really small ones that make $200,000, $500,000 a year, right? Something less than that, $5,000, $20,000 a year, right? Like, they certainly can’t do this kind of stuff.
But even the nonprofits that have, you know, two, three million annual revenue, four, five million, their ability to do the kinds of tasks that are being suggested at these conferences seems to me to be incongruous with what's actually being asked.
So, for me, I look at the quantity argument and just think, if I'm running a nonprofit, it sure sounds nice. But if my biggest issue as a nonprofit executive director is that I'm already a little uncertain about marketing, a little uncertain about storytelling — it's not my instinct, not why I got into this work — why am I then going to invest in channel upon channel of most likely mediocre content that doesn't achieve whatever your goals are?
Now, when it comes to quality, I think, as a nonprofit, you have to be very intentional about your investments. The more you can communicate clearly, and the more that you can isolate your communication to the people who you're specifically trying to reach, the more that you can make the most of it, and the more that you can actually get the results that you're looking for.
So, for example, I look at the work I do. When people hire me to craft a nonprofit video, to do video storytelling, they're often looking for a mission video, or they're looking for a gala video. Most likely, this video is going to run at some major event, usually a fundraising event. And at that event, you have a captive audience, a hopefully captivated audience, and an audience that is looking to donate large sums of money.
That's when you invest in a video, because for the thousands of dollars that you might invest, the return on that should be so far beyond what you're spending. It should be a multiple of what you're spending. It should absolutely make that kind of a difference.
So that's where I look at it and say that’s intentional spending, right? That's intentional storytelling: having a video you can then turn around and use when you're applying for grant proposals, put it on the front of your website. That all makes sense, because you will be bringing back so much more in terms of fundraising than whatever you spent to hire a videographer, if that videographer does it right, right?
So that's part of it.
But what about just general storytelling, right? Like, what about the more consistent social media storytelling?
I would still say that the goal is to master one or two platforms before spreading yourself too thin on all of them.
And particularly, unless you have a dedicated marketing person who can A/B test, who can really put the energy into crunching numbers, determining what the best options are, not just blindly plugging everything into an AI platform of some sort, unless you've got that person, you're not going to be able to keep up with the demands of seven, eight different platforms.
So I would say, while there absolutely is a long-term benefit to iteration and A/B testing and all the things that so many of these speakers are talking about, that requires the staffing to be able to handle it. And that requires the staffing to be able to truly understand the goals and truly monitor what's taking place, so that the work they're doing isn't just busy work. It isn't just getting themselves on YouTube or as a podcast.
Because you just need somebody to do all of this. And it should be someone who can do it effectively
If you were a massive nonprofit with an eight-figure annual revenue, I would say, sure. Go ahead and invest in YouTube, podcast—I would do the whole thing.
Now let me pause here and share this perspective: I'm no stranger to this because I am a one-person business. I'm a business owner of a one-person business, right? And I am trying to reach people, right? I truly believe in the service I provide, but if nobody is aware it exists, how are they going to know to reach out to me, right?
So I face that tension all the time. And I try to handle that in various ways, right? In my two years in business, I have tried many different ways of connecting with people. But when it comes specifically to social media, right, I knew right away that my audience is going to be on LinkedIn. And that was tough for me, because I'd built large followings on Instagram and Facebook during my days as a reporter.
And I still occasionally post there, because, A, I want people who followed me then to know what I'm doing now, and B, you never know when somebody who was a Facebook or Instagram follower during my reporting days might be interested in the services I provide.
But in terms of bang for my buck, it is about LinkedIn. And I need to stay hyper-focused there. Because I am just one person, and I want to reserve my energy for doing the work that people hire me to do, I've got to be very selective, right?
I would say the same thing about this very podcast that you're listening to.
So, I had a podcast for a long time when I was a reporter, and I would do an episode usually every other week, sometimes once a month, depending on how busy my schedule was at work.
There was no pressure to do it, right? Like, it was not something that was part of my job at work. It was literally something I was doing extra, not making any money off of it, right? There were no ads, just like there were no ads on this podcast. It wasn't a revenue machine for me in any way.
But it was something that I valued doing. It was a great way to raise the conversation about storytelling in places where I felt like that was needed. I had achieved a certain amount of success in journalism and felt like, especially for younger journalists, that my podcast could be a resource. And I still hear from people today, years after stopping the podcast, that it is a resource for some.
So I think that's really cool.
Now obviously I stopped that podcast when I moved into this work, and I decided to start this podcast for a couple of reasons.
One, because I valued the experience of having a podcast previously. I valued the ability to help shape the conversation in some ways and help interview people and help uplift people who are doing tremendous work, which is why every episode other than this one, you don't hear just me. You're mostly hearing me interviewing people and giving them the spotlight so that they can shine and really share their message, because it's valuable. And the things that they know about storytelling are valuable.
But, again, I also had to decide how much time to dedicate to this. And I know that every minute that I spend doing something like a podcast is a minute that I then don't have to do the work that people hire me to do.
So that is why I only come out with one episode every month. And that's it. One episode a month. Occasionally, if things are really, really busy, I might even skip a month here and there. But for the most part, it's once a month, and that is the perfect amount for me, right?
So if you think about it, I do have a presence on YouTube and in the podcast circuit, because I do this, and I have a new episode every month.
So I am there.
And I would say that because I only do one a month, because I'm not trying to be a weekly podcaster, when you listen to an episode, you know it's going to be worth it. And you know you're getting my best, and you're not just getting, you know, you're not just getting fluff that was scripted by AI.
You are getting solid stuff every time you see an episode pop up wherever you get your podcast. At least that's how it should be. You tell me if that's not the case.
So for me as a solopreneur, those are the kinds of decisions that I'm making often, right?
Ideally, I would be spending most of my time, if not all of it, doing the work that people hire me to do—video production, video storytelling, all of that.
But I also understand, just like those of you in the nonprofit space probably wish that you could just spend 90 to 100% of your time only focused on your operations and your program, that that's not the world we live in.
You have to also have fundraising efforts going on. You also have to think about marketing. You have to think about storytelling. Because at the end of the day, you need money to be able to do the work you love.
And same for me. I need clients who are willing to pay me to do the work that I love to do, the work that I believe in, the same way you believe in the work that you do, right?
This isn't selfish, necessarily. It's very much from a good place and from a holistic place. But we can't ignore the realities of the world.
So, I would say that those are the decisions that we have to think about, and we have to think about intentionally.
Even with the number of AI options available, I just don't love the idea of turning over your entire marketing division to that. I do see value in some of the content creation and content repurposing apps that are out there. But if you don't have the content, it's not going to matter. And if you don't have the content, then you really shouldn't be trying to expand your marketing output without the foundational content to make it worthwhile.
So that's my big message.
And I would say that these are very challenging times, right?
On the one hand, forget about our work with nonprofits, we know that in our lives, we are bombarded with emails, subscriptions, text messages for things that we didn't even know that we signed up for, right? Whether it's companies or politicians. We are bombarded, and we are overwhelmed.
And I don't know about you, but I don't want to be part of that. I don't want to contribute to that.
And I would imagine, as a nonprofit, that's probably where you are, too. If you got into a line of work that is dedicated to bettering the world in one way or another, you probably aren't interested in annoying everyone else in the process.
And yet, we know that we still have to figure out how to reach people.
And I think that is the big challenge.
The easy answer is, well, just join the parade. And just join the masses of people who are flooding us with emails and texts every chance they get.
That's an easy solution in theory. But one, I don't necessarily think it works. And two, I don't think most of us want to be a part of that.
So, the question is, how then do we accomplish our fundraising goals, our awareness goals, without bombarding?
And I think that's where I just come back to this idea of leading with quality content, understanding what that is, identifying it, identifying the content that meets the goals you're trying to meet and that reaches the audience you're trying to reach. And I think that is where—that's where most of our energy should be spent in this space.
So that's my advice.
I think it's easy to go to conferences and be tempted by the allure of AI, and be tempted by the allure of just being everywhere, of being omnipresent when it comes to social media and emails, and just being a nonstop presence in our people's lives.
I don't think it is the way to achieve a lot of what we're trying to achieve.
And I think right now, it seems like an easy fix, and because people haven't experienced it much yet, it is seductive in that way as well.
I’m not dismissing AI or any kind of emerging technology. I embrace it when I feel like it can do the job it purports to do. And the tools are evolving and changing by the day. The platforms that we use to reach people, or where we try to reach people, are evolving and changing by the day.
So here’s what I would say: Be aware of all of it. Try to stay on top of those conversations. Don't commit to something until you're sure it will be effective for you. And just remember that at the end of the day, you're doing all of this for a reason. And whatever that reason is, that should be at the forefront of your mind, no matter what shiny new object tempts you away.
That is Episode 20 of Dot Org. If you found this helpful and want others to hear it too, a great rating or review where you get your podcasts goes a long way. Please take the time if you can. And check out my work at Pearl Impact Media. Video storytelling can be so beneficial for organizations. I’d love to work with yours. Book a free consultation at pearl-impact-media-dot-com. All right, friends: I am Matt Pearl. Thanks for listening to Dot Org. See you next time.
Matt Pearl is the founder of Pearl Impact Media, where he specializes in nonprofit video storytelling and production. A nationally award-winning journalist with 20+ years of video storytelling experience, he now helps organizations turn their stories into signature assets used across fundraising campaigns, donor communications, and major events and galas.



